6 ways for retailers to reduce the credit card processing fee

The amount of fees depends on various factors:

• Type of business: Payment processors apply different credit card processing rates for different business types based on your registered Merchant Category Code (MCC) such as supermarket, retail, travel, and fuel.
• B2B businesses: B2B companies, such as large-volume or government suppliers can get Level 2 and Level 3 processing for lower credit card processing rates. However, this kind of discount isn’t applicable for companies that have traditional eCommerce or physical terminals.
• High-risk level businesses: If the payment processors classify your business as high-risk level due to the nature of your products and services, or high chargeback history, you’ll have to open a dedicated account for high-risk sellers. This will add up to your credit card processing fees.
• Type of transaction: Card-present transactions (swipe cards or hovering NFC/chip at POS terminals) often come with lower processing fees than card-not-present transactions (online and telephone orders). The higher risk, the higher the fees.

The average credit card processing fee is 1.5–3.5% per transaction.

• For in-person transactions, the average fee is closer to 2%.
• For card-not-present and online payments, the average fee is around 3%.

In addition, the average credit card processing fee can vary between different credit card networks. We’d like to provide a comparison table of credit card processing rates of major brands.

(*) Note: This fee hasn’t included the processor markup fee, which depends on the processor you use.

While large retailers with high volume transactions can get discounts and lower rates, small retailers suffer higher ones. Lowering the rate just by some minor percent can save you a lot.

For example, your rate is 2% and your total credit card transaction value is $500,000, you need to pay $10,000 for processing fees. However, this fee is down to $8,000 if your rate is 1.6%.

Although merchants can’t avoid it entirely, we’ll discuss 6 ways that you can reduce the credit card processing fee.

1. Choose the right pricing models

In general, payment service providers will offer you 3 main pricing plans. There is no best option for all cases. It depends on your business growth, transaction type, and volume to choose the right pricing model.

Flat rate or blended pricing

Regardless of your customer card type, you’ll pay a fixed fee for each transaction. This fee structure makes an affordable, reasonable, and transparent budget – a suitable choice for small and start-up businesses.

Interchange-plus or cost-plus pricing

This model has 2 parts: the markup determined by the credit card processor and the interchange fee set by the card network. You can choose to pay a flat markup fee by a fixed amount or percentage. This is suitable for most companies and easier to budget options for scale-up and large businesses.

Subscription or membership pricing

Like interchange-plus, merchants only need to pay a flat monthly fee, which covers assessment and interchange fees. For markup fee, you’ll pay 5–10 cents per transaction. This model is a great option for small and growing businesses.

We summarize the credit card processing fee comparison by pricing model in the table below, which considers the most popular payment service providers in the market.

Let’s analyze an example to distinguish the credit card processing fees of these pricing models better. Imagine that you have monthly transactions as follows:

• 100 transactions of $200
• 100 transactions of $100
• 100 transactions of $50
• 100 transactions of $10

Here is how you pay for the processing fee according to your chosen pricing model.

This clearly proves that:

• Flat rate is suitable for small retail, but not good for a high volume of transactions.
• SMEs with higher transaction values may prefer subscription or interchange-plus pricing.

Choosing the right payment solution is essential to optimize payment processing fees for your business. If you operate your business on eCommerce platforms, you should carefully understand how they support payments.

For instance, Shopify encourages merchants to use Shopify Payments, and if merchants choose third-party payment solutions for online transactions, extra fees are applied. For in-store transactions, Shopify POS only accepts Shopify Payments. Opting for a third-party POS solution can provide more flexibility, as some POS systems integrate with other payment options.

Magestore’s Stripe POS enables you to process payments with Stripe. And of course, in addition to Stripe, Magestore POS also can integrate with multiple local payment gateways based on your country and region, such as Square, Adyen, Verifone, Authorize.net, etc.

2. Negotiate the markup fee with credit card processors

As mentioned in the previous part, while you can’t negotiate interchange and assessment fees, the markup fee determined by the merchant account provider is negotiable.

Basically, a higher volume usually comes with a lower rate. Presenting yourself as a value-added merchant with high transaction volume is the best way to negotiate.

Thus, you should propose your expected sales in the coming years and demonstrate your annual growth. The payment processors can offer you a discount if your volume is large enough for them to negotiate with their suppliers.

The next thing to negotiate is how to calculate the markup fee. For larger value transactions, the percentage effect is larger than the flat fee per transaction. Let’s compare 2 transactions with the markup fee of 0.5% + $0.15:

• $100 transaction: $0.50 + $0.15
• $10 transaction: $0.05 + $0.15

It means that:

• With low-value transactions, you should negotiate the fee per transaction and can reduce it from $0.05–0.10 per transaction. It sounds small, but after 2,000 trades, you’ll reduce $100–200.
• With high-value transactions, you should negotiate for a lower percentage fee. Assuming the fee goes from 0.5% to 0.4% you will reduce $0.10 per transaction.

3. Reduce the risk of credit card fraud

Part of the processing fee is to cover the risks for your issuing bank and payment processor.

If you’re a high-risk merchant, your payment processors will charge you higher credit card processing fees. On the contrary, processors will reduce rates when you can demonstrate that your business is less prone to fraudulent activity and credit risk.

It’s a good idea to highlight some anti-fraud methods in your negotiation proposal:

• Demonstrate a clear refund and return policy
• Comply with PCI standards
• Swipe credit cards instead of keyed transactions
• Enter the security information to validate the payment and protect the cardholder
• Request a CVV for card-not-present transactions
• Request signatures for delivered orders
• Fill in the ZIP code in the billing address
• Save receipts and keep transaction history
• Use EMV card readers
• Stay updated with the latest technology and equip the right POS terminal

Not only will it reduce your credit card processing fee, it also lowers the risk of retail fraud, putting less strain on your business.

4. Use an address verification service

To increase your security level and reduce payment processing fees, you should use an address verification service (AVS) to verify the card issuer of the cardholder’s billing address.

• Customers enter their address during the checkout process.
• The AVS system compares if the filled in information matches with the registered address in the customer’s file at the issuing bank.
• After completing the comparison, the bank will send the merchant an AVS code.
  The merchant uses that code to decline or complete the transaction.

This anti-fraud system reduces the rate of chargebacks or refunds for both in-store and online purchases. It’s especially beneficial for eCommerce businesses. MasterCard and Visa both support AVS and encourage all businesses to use AVS.

5. Set up your merchant account and terminal properly

Credit card processing fees depend in part on the characteristics of your business. As a result, setting up your account wrongly and providing incorrect business information will affect the structure of your credit card processing cost and increase credit card processing fees. You should set up properly and standardize your account information from the beginning:

• Choose the right business type, transaction type, and frequency
• Set a credit card minimum, around $10 for credit card purchase to avoid high fees per transaction for small order value
• Add a credit card surcharge, in which their customers pay the processing fee for their credit card transaction

Also, the settings of your terminals affect the processing fee. The more transactions and the longer the waiting time, the higher the credit card processing rates and fees. Here are some ways to reduce the cost:

• Proceed transactions within 24 hours to reduce the number of transactions
• Perform a transaction batch every day instead of every few days or weeks

6. Get payment processing from your POS provider

To reduce credit card processing costs for small businesses, you might consider working with one provider for both credit card processing and POS solutions to:

• Simplify your payment processing
• Eliminate additional costs like integration fees or fraud prevention fees

You’ll have seamless integration and if your business qualifies for credit cards processing discounts, you can lower the overall fees.

For any business, the credit card processing fee isn’t a small expense. You can negotiate the markup fee, increase your security level, set up standard accounts and terminals, and implement some rules for credit cards to minimize your credit card processing cost.

Each processor has a different pricing model so it’s important that you understand where the charges come from and what factors affect the rates.

• If you’re a seasonal and small business, you should go with the flat rate pricing model and choose a payment service provider who doesn’t require a long-term contract.
• If you’re a medium business and handle a high monthly transaction volume, you should opt for an interchange-plus pricing model.
• If you’re a large business, you may prefer the membership/subscription model to reduce credit card processing fees.